Nostalgic Candy

Your favorite retro candies that remind you of your youth.

Sort By:
Show:

Bonomo Chocolate Taffy

$2.25
It's Back!! Bonomo's Turkish Taffy, the chewy, taffy-like candy bar we've all been missing! Enjoy th..

Abba Zabba

$2.49
Abba Zaba is a chewy taffy bar filled with a rich creamy peanut butter center. ..

Nostalgic Big Cherry Candy

$2.50
Nostalgic Big Cherry Candy ..

Assorted Ring Pops

$1.49
Assorted variety of Ring Pops ..

Oh Henry! Candy Bar

$2.19
Oh Henry! Candy Bar ..

Cow Tales Chocolate

$0.79
Cow Tales are a chewy caramel with a chocolate cream center, yum! ..

Chocolate Charleston Chew

$2.49
Enjoy this chewy chocolate flavored nougat candy bar with a delicious chocolate coating, yum! ..

Bonomo Banana Taffy

$2.25
It's Back!! Bonomo's Turkish Taffy, the chewy, taffy-like candy bar we've all been missing! Enjoy th..

Zotz String Candy

$0.95
Choose from 3 different flavors: Blue Raspberry, Orange or Grape. Each "String" comes with 4 of t..

Strawberry Zotz String

$0.95
Zotz are a hard candy with a fizzy sour center. Each "string" has 4 pieces of a single flavor.&nb..

Strawberry Abba Zaba

$2.49
A Strawberry Abba Zaba, a taffy candy bar with a peanut butter center...

Cow Tales Strawberry

$0.79
Cow Tales are a chewy caramel with a strawberry cream center, yum!..

Charleston Chew Strawberry

$2.49
Enjoy this chewy strawberry flavored nougat candy bar with a delicious chocolate coating, yum! ..

Candy Bottle Caps

$2.49
Tart bite-sized candies made to look like soda bottle caps. Each package has a variety of caps in as..

Bit-O-Honey Bar

$2.49
Enjoy a delicious Bit-O-Honey bar -- a chewy candy with almond bits blended into a honey flavored ta..
Showing 1 to 15 of 16 (2 Pages)